Cardinal Joseph Tobin, the Archbishop of the Diocese of Newark, has announced a comprehensive third-party review of a 2019 investigation into sexual abuse allegations at Seton Hall University. The decision follows recent scrutiny over the university’s promotion of Monsignor Joseph Reilly, despite prior recommendations for his removal from leadership roles due to his handling of past abuse allegations.
Background of the Investigation
The 2019 investigation was conducted by the law firm Latham & Watkins following credible allegations against former Cardinal Theodore McCarrick. McCarrick, a once-prominent Catholic leader, was accused of decades of sexual abuse. As part of the investigation, findings revealed that Monsignor Joseph Reilly, then the rector and dean of Seton Hall’s Immaculate Conception Seminary, failed to properly report sexual abuse allegations.
While Reilly was not accused of committing abuse, investigators found that he was aware of allegations but did not adhere to proper reporting procedures under the university’s and federal Title IX policies. Despite this, Seton Hall University promoted Reilly to the presidency, leading to widespread criticism from lawmakers and New Jersey Governor Phil Murphy, who urged the university to release its internal report on Reilly.
Cardinal Tobin’s Response
Cardinal Tobin has now enlisted the law firm Ropes & Gray to conduct a thorough review of the original investigation and the subsequent findings. According to Tobin’s statement:
“The review by Ropes & Gray will include how the findings of these reports relate to Monsignor Joseph Reilly, including whether they were communicated to any and all appropriate personnel at the Archdiocese and Seton Hall University and Monsignor Reilly, and if so, by what means and by whom.”
Tobin emphasized that the review will be conducted transparently and without restrictions, ensuring all relevant facts and investigative avenues are explored.
Seton Hall’s Position
Despite mounting pressure, Seton Hall University has defended Reilly. Hank D’Alessandro, Chair of the Board of Regents, stated:
“Recent news stories have falsely and unfairly portrayed him.”
The university has so far ignored calls to release its internal report. However, the findings of the 2019 investigation remain a cause for concern, particularly regarding Reilly’s handling of past abuse complaints, including:
- Investigating a student complaint of sexual assault internally without following school or federal policies.
- Dismissing an alleged victim of sexual abuse in 2012 without properly investigating the incident.
- Failing to report a 2014 sexual harassment allegation at St. Andrew’s Hall, a seminary within Seton Hall.
Broader Implications
This controversy highlights ongoing challenges in the Catholic Church regarding transparency and accountability in handling sexual abuse allegations. Seton Hall, as a diocesan university under the authority of the Archdiocese of Newark, operates under church leadership, with Cardinal Tobin serving as both the president of its Board of Regents and chair of the Board of Trustees.
Tobin acknowledged the church’s past failures, stating:
“Countless stories and reports make it clear that the Catholic Church has breached the trust that is at the core of its mission to provide spiritual guidance, support, and healing to those in need.”
He reaffirmed his commitment to restoring trust and ensuring accountability within the church.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why is Cardinal Tobin initiating a new review now?
Recent media reports and public outcry have raised concerns about how the findings of the 2019 investigation were handled. The review aims to provide transparency and ensure accountability in how sexual abuse allegations were managed.
2. Was Monsignor Joseph Reilly accused of sexual abuse?
No, Reilly was not accused of abuse. However, he was found to have mishandled allegations by failing to report them appropriately and not adhering to institutional policies.
3. What is Ropes & Gray’s role in the new investigation?
The law firm will conduct an independent and comprehensive review of the 2019 investigation’s findings, how they were communicated, and whether appropriate actions were taken.
4. Has Seton Hall University responded to the controversy?
Seton Hall has defended Reilly and has not released the full report detailing the allegations against him. The university’s Board of Regents has stood by Reilly despite calls for his resignation.
5. What are the next steps in this review process?
There is no set timeline for the review, but Tobin has assured that it will be thorough and unrestricted. The findings may lead to further actions depending on what is uncovered.
Conclusion
The renewed investigation into Seton Hall University’s handling of sexual abuse allegations underscores the Catholic Church’s ongoing struggle with accountability and transparency. Cardinal Tobin’s decision to commission a third-party review demonstrates an effort to address concerns and rebuild trust.
However, whether this initiative will lead to meaningful changes remains to be seen. As the review unfolds, both the church and the university will face continued scrutiny regarding their commitment to justice and institutional integrity.
